COMPACTION AND VEGETATION
Everything we do has some effect on the environment. When a hiker
steps on a flower, he affects the environment. When land is paved over
for a bicycle path, it affects the environment. Many of the foot paths
man has used for centuries still exist and are clearly visible
throughout the world.
However, it’s a fact that a snowmobile and rider exert
dramatically less pressure on the earth’s surface than other
recreational activities (i.e., just one-tenth the pressure of a hiker
and one-sixteenth the pressure of a horseback rider). Average pounds of
pressure per square inch exerted on earth’s surface:
|
Object | Lbs. of Pressure |
| Four-Wheel Drive Vehicle | 30 |
| Horse | 8 |
| Man | 5 |
| All-Terrain Vehicle | 1.5 |
| Snowmobile | 0.5 |
(All vehicle weights considered include 210 lbs. estimated weight of one
person and gear.)
Moreover, the snowmobile’s 1/2 pound of pressure is further reduced by
an intervening blanket of snow.
In many jurisdictions, snowmobiles are not classified as off-road
vehicles. By both definition and management policies, these
jurisdictions have completely separated snowmobiles from off-road
vehicles. As the U.S. Department of the Interior concluded in an
environmental statement:
"A major distinction is warranted between snowmobiles and
other types of off-road vehicles. Snowmobiles operated on an adequate
snow cover have little effect on soils - and hence cause less severe
indirect impacts on air and water quality, and on soil- dependent biotic
communities, than other ORV’s do."
Given adequate snowfall and responsible operation, all evidence
of snowmobile operation disappears when the season changes and the snow
melts.
In its environmental statement regarding off-road vehicle use of
public lands, the U.S. Department of the Interior stated:
"Where
snowmobiles are used exclusively over snow on roads and trails, the
impact on vegetation is indeed virtually nil."
A University of Wisconsin study of J. W. Pendleton entitled
Effect
of Snowmobile Traffic on Non-Forest Vegetation discovered that
snowmobile traffic had no effect on grain yield of winter wheat,
alfalfa, red clover plots or grass legume. Species of turf grass showed
slightly reduced yields at first harvest, but were not negatively
affected in subsequent harvests.
Research undertaken by Dr. James C. Wittaker and Dennis S.
Wentworth of the University of Maine concluded that “compaction by
snowmobiling does not alter the grain weight yields of alfalfa in
Maine.”
A Utah Water Resource Laboratory study found that snow
compaction, caused by snowmobile tracks, does not damage wheat crops.
Instead, the compaction
increases the yield and eliminates snow
mold. Erosion is also reduced.
There is no evidence that snow compaction caused by
snowmobiling, ski-touring or snowshoeing has a significant impact on the
population of small burrowing animals. Since these recreations take
place over a minuscule portion of the total land area, the ecosystems of
burrowing animals tend to be overwhelmingly affected by natural
forces-such as wind-induced compaction, early and late snowfalls,
temperature fluctuations resulting in thaws and freezes, etc.